Father John Misty was on The Late Show With Stephen Colbert earlier this month, and although he gave an intense performance of "Holy S---," Josh Tillman also had another brand new song at the ready.

He wrote "Maybe, Sweet One, You Won't Have Nightmares Tonight" for use in a skit on the show, but (according to Misty's SoundCloud) it was cut for time. Instead, Tillman posted it today.

Although the music sounds like an innocuous lullaby, the lyrics grow increasingly nightmarish in line with Tillman's increasingly prevalent razor-sharp wit. Give it a listen below.