Soundgarden finally hit on something with 1994’s ‘Superunknown.’ It helped that the rest of the nation finally caught up with their sludgy mix of Seattle punk and Sabbath-inspired doom metal. But after three albums of increasingly heavy and thundering sounds, Soundgarden reached No. 1 with a record that threw an artsy expansion pack in there. So when they followed up ‘Superunknown’ two years later with ‘Down on the Up Side,’ it was only in the natural order of things that would lead them to continue on this experimental path.

‘Down on the Upside,’ which celebrates its 17th anniversary today, downplays the band’s heavier tendencies in favor of mandolins and piano and splashes of psychedelia that were ultimately weightier than any of the down-tuned guitars that cut away on the band’s earlier albums. Not everyone in Soundgarden was happy with this move. Tensions between singer Chris Cornell and guitarist Kim Thayil got to the point where pretty much everyone knew that this could be the group’s last record.

But for all the changes and mixing up, ‘Down on the Upside’ doesn’t sound all that different than ‘Superunknown,’ which began the group’s migration toward this direction. The band coproduced the record with Adam Kasper, who worked as an assistant engineer on ‘Superunknown.’ So the album’s best songs – ‘Pretty Noose,’ ‘Rhinosaur,’ ‘Ty Cobb,’ ‘Blow Up the Outside World,’ ‘Burden in My Hand’ – sound like extensions of ‘Superunknown’ with some modifications.

The album debuted at No. 2 and indeed turned out to be Soundgarden’s last until 2012’s reunion record. It sold a million copies and spawned four singles, three of which reached the rock and modern-rock Top 10 charts. ‘Pretty Noose’ and ‘Burden in My Hand’ even cracked the Top 40. Today, ‘Down on the Upside’ stands as Soundgarden’s most ambitious record. But back when it came out, it sounded like it was tearing them apart. And it eventually did.

More From